
If you own a property in Hertfordshire and you have trees in your garden, this article is directly relevant to you. Particularly after the summer we have just had.
The UK recorded its hottest summer on record in 2026, with four separate heatwave events between May and August. The ground dried out to levels the British Geological Survey described as record-breaking across eastern England. And when clay soil dries out beneath a house, the foundations can move. That is subsidence, and right now it is happening at a scale the insurance industry has not seen before.
The Association of British Insurers reported that the average domestic subsidence claim hit a record £20,000 in the second quarter of 2026. Insurers paid out £72 million on domestic subsidence in that three-month period alone, up from £60 million the year before. Hastings, one of the major home insurers, reported a 140% year-on-year increase in subsidence claims by August. Aviva and AXA have both flagged 2026 as a surge year.
Trees are at the centre of a large proportion of these claims. And Hertfordshire, sitting on some of the most shrinkable clay in the country, is one of the areas most affected.
How Trees Cause Subsidence
Subsidence is not caused by tree roots pushing foundations apart. That is a common misunderstanding. The actual mechanism is soil moisture extraction.
Trees absorb water from the soil through their root systems. On stable, sandy or chalky ground, this has very little effect on the soil volume. But on clay, it is a different story. Clay particles hold water between them, and when that water is removed, the clay shrinks. If a tree is drawing large volumes of water from the clay beneath or near a building’s foundations, the soil shrinks unevenly, the ground drops on one side, and the foundations move. That differential movement is what cracks walls, jams doors, and, in serious cases, makes a property structurally unsafe.
The key word is “differential.” If the whole ground dropped evenly, you would barely notice. The damage comes when one part of a building moves and another part does not.
Which Trees Cause the Most Problems
Not all trees pose the same risk. The critical factor is water demand. High water-demand species pull enormous volumes of moisture from the ground, and their root systems can extend a long way from the trunk.
The species most commonly associated with subsidence claims in the UK are oak, poplar, willow, and elm. Oak alone accounts for the largest share of tree-related subsidence cases nationally, according to the RHS. That is partly because oaks are so common, partly because they are large, and partly because they have extensive root networks with high water uptake.
Other high water-demand species include eucalyptus and several common conifers, particularly Leyland cypress, Lawson cypress, and Monterey cypress. Leyland cypress hedges are worth singling out because they are everywhere in Hertfordshire gardens, often planted close to boundaries and buildings. A row of them can have a cumulative drying effect on the soil that rivals a single large tree.
Lower-risk species include birch, hazel, magnolia, elder, and most ornamental conifers like pine and spruce. That does not mean they are risk-free, just that their water demand is lower, and the soil drying effect is smaller.
A useful rule of thumb from the RHS: for high water-demand species, the soil drying effect can extend outward to a distance equal to the tree’s mature height. For intermediate and low water-demand species, the effect is unlikely to reach further than half the tree’s height. So a 20-metre oak could be affecting the soil up to 20 metres away. That covers a lot of gardens.
Why Hertfordshire Is Particularly at Risk
Subsidence is overwhelmingly a clay soil problem. The highest-risk areas in the UK form a belt running through London, the Home Counties, Essex, Kent, and from Oxford across to the Wash on England’s east coast. Hertfordshire sits squarely within that belt.
Large parts of the county sit on London Clay and other shrinkable clay formations. St Albans, Welwyn Garden City, Hatfield, Potters Bar, Brookmans Park, and much of the surrounding area are on clay or clay-dominant soils. If you are not sure what your soil type is, you can check using the British Geological Survey’s free Geology of Britain Viewer online.
The other factor is building age. Properties built before 1950, and especially Victorian and Edwardian houses, typically have shallow foundations, sometimes as little as 300mm to 600mm deep. Modern buildings constructed after about 1980 generally have deeper foundations designed with trees in mind, following NHBC guidelines. But older properties, which make up a large proportion of the housing stock in towns like St Albans and Welwyn, are significantly more vulnerable to soil movement.
The combination of shrinkable clay soil, older properties with shallow foundations, and mature trees is exactly the scenario that produces subsidence claims. Hertfordshire has all three in abundance.
How to Spot the Warning Signs
Subsidence does not usually announce itself with a sudden dramatic crack. It develops gradually, and the signs often build up over months or years. Here is what to look for.
Diagonal cracks in walls, particularly around doors and windows. These are the classic indicator. Subsidence cracks tend to run diagonally, are wider at the top than the bottom, and are often more visible externally than internally. They typically appear where the building is weakest, around openings. Hairline cracks are common in most buildings and usually mean nothing. The threshold to watch for is cracks wider than about 3mm, or any crack that you can see daylight through.
Doors and windows that stick or will not close properly. If a door that used to open and close easily now jams, or a window that used to sit flush in its frame no longer does, the frame may have moved. This is especially significant if it happens in dry weather and partially corrects itself in winter when the ground rehydrates.
Cracks that open in summer and close in winter. This seasonal pattern is one of the strongest indicators that the movement is related to clay shrinkage. If you have a crack that widens during hot, dry weather and narrows when it rains, the soil beneath the building is almost certainly moving with the moisture content. That seasonal cycle is characteristic of tree-related subsidence.
Rippling or distortion in wallpaper. Sometimes internal cracking is hidden by wallpaper, but you can see the distortion as ripples or wrinkles near the ceiling or around door frames.
Gaps appearing between walls and the floor, or between the house and an extension. Extensions are particularly vulnerable because they often have shallower foundations than the main building and may be founded at a different depth.
About 5 to 10mm of ground movement is usually needed before visible cracking develops. Below that threshold, the building can generally absorb the movement without damage. But once cracking starts, it tends to get worse if the underlying cause is not addressed.
What You Should Do If You Suspect Subsidence
If you are seeing the signs described above and you have trees near your property, here is a practical course of action.
First, do not panic and do not start cutting trees down. That is counterintuitive, but it is important. Removing a tree that has been drawing moisture from clay for decades can cause a separate problem called heave. When the tree is no longer extracting water, the clay gradually rehydrates and swells. The ground rises, and that upward movement can cause as much structural damage as the original subsidence. On London Clay, heave after tree removal can take years to stabilise and, in some cases, requires underpinning to manage. Removing a tree without understanding the heave risk can make a bad situation significantly worse.
Second, document what you are seeing. Photograph the cracks, measure their width, and note the date. Do this at regular intervals so you can show whether the cracks are getting worse, staying the same, or closing up in wet weather. This evidence will be useful for both your insurer and any professional you consult.
Third, contact your home insurer. Subsidence is covered under most standard home insurance policies, though there is usually an excess, and that excess has been rising. Excesses above £1,000 are now common, and properties with a subsidence history can face excesses of up to £10,000. Your insurer will typically send a surveyor or loss adjuster to assess the situation. They may also commission a tree report.
Fourth, get an independent arboricultural assessment. Your insurer’s surveyor will focus on the building. A qualified arborist focuses on the tree. An arboricultural report will identify the species, assess its water demand, evaluate its proximity to the building, and recommend a proportionate course of action. That might be crown reduction to lower the tree’s water uptake, ongoing monitoring, root management, or, in some cases, removal, but only after the heave risk has been properly assessed.
Fifth, check whether the tree is protected. If there is a Tree Preservation Order on the tree, or your property is within a conservation area, you need consent from your local planning authority before carrying out any work, including pruning. An insurer telling you to remove a tree is not a legal exemption from TPO protection. Unauthorised work on a protected tree can result in fines of up to £20,000 in a magistrates’ court or an unlimited fine in the Crown Court.
Crown Reduction: The Middle Ground
In many subsidence cases, the recommended approach is not removal but crown reduction. This involves reducing the overall volume of the tree’s canopy, which in turn reduces its water uptake from the soil.
For crown reduction to be effective as a subsidence management tool, the reduction needs to be significant. The RHS notes that reducing crown volume by at least 70% is typically needed, and the work needs repeating roughly every three years as the crown regrows. A light trim or a standard crown thin will not meaningfully reduce water uptake.
This is specialist work. A 70% crown reduction on a mature oak is a very different job from tidying up a garden tree, and it needs to be done in a way that leaves the tree balanced, structurally sound, and capable of recovering. Poorly executed crown reduction can leave a tree stressed, prone to disease, and aesthetically ruined.
Crown reduction is often the preferred option where the tree is protected by a TPO, where removal would carry a heave risk, or where the tree has significant amenity or ecological value. Councils and insurers are generally more supportive of management than removal, provided the management plan is credible and the work is carried out by a qualified contractor.
The Bigger Picture: Climate Change and Subsidence
This is not a one-off problem. The pattern of hotter, drier summers and warmer, wetter winters that the UK has experienced in recent years is projected to continue and intensify. Timothy Farewell of MapleSky, which advises 20 major UK insurers on ground movement, has pointed out that widespread soil drying events have occurred in 2018, 2022, 2025, and 2026. The intervals are getting shorter.
The British Geological Survey’s projections suggest that under the worst-case climate scenario, more than 4.2 million UK properties, around 11% of the total housing stock, could be at risk of subsidence by 2070. That number is not evenly distributed. Clay-soil areas like Hertfordshire will bear a disproportionate share.
For homeowners, this means that trees and buildings need to be thought about together, not separately. The tree that was planted 30 years ago when the climate was cooler and wetter may now be extracting more moisture from the soil than it used to, simply because the summers are longer and drier. A tree that caused no problems for decades can become a subsidence risk as the climate shifts.
That does not mean you should remove every tree near your house. Trees provide shade that can make areas up to 5°C cooler, they absorb carbon, they support wildlife, and they add significant value to a property. The answer is management, not removal. Know what species you have, understand their water demand, get them surveyed if they are near buildings on clay, and put a management plan in place before a problem develops.
What This Means for You This Autumn
October is a good time to take stock. The summer’s damage to foundations, if any, is done. The ground is beginning to rehydrate as autumn rain arrives. Cracks that opened over the summer may start to close, but the movement they represent has already happened.
If you have noticed new cracking this year, do not assume it will fix itself. Seasonal closure does not mean the problem is resolved. It means the soil is swelling back, but next summer it will shrink again, potentially further than before. Each cycle can make the damage worse.
If you have mature trees near your property, particularly oak, willow, poplar, or large Leyland cypress hedges, and your home is on clay soil, it is worth getting a professional assessment now, before next summer. A tree survey can identify which trees pose a risk, what management is needed, and whether any immediate action is required.
If you have trees near your property and you are concerned about subsidence, call us on 01707 708202 or get in touch through our website for a free, no-obligation assessment. We will tell you what you are dealing with, whether it needs action now or monitoring, and what your options are, including whether the best course of action is simply to leave things as they are.